Lyme Homes for Sale

Lyme Homes for Sale

Welcome to Lyme, New York – a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Jefferson County. This charming town, bordered by the breathtaking shores of the St. Lawrence River, offers a unique blend of serene natural beauty and a tight-knit community atmosphere. Known for its stunning landscapes, Lyme is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts, with ample opportunities for boating, fishing, hiking, and exploring the rich wildlife of the nearby Thousand Islands region.

As you stroll through the quaint streets of Lyme, you’ll be captivated by the warm sense of community and the welcoming spirit of its residents. The town boasts a variety of local shops, cozy eateries, and seasonal farmers' markets, making it easy to enjoy the simple pleasures of small-town living. Whether you’re looking to retire in peace, raise a family, or find a vacation getaway, Lyme offers an idyllic setting that caters to all lifestyles.

For those searching for homes for sale, Lyme presents an array of options that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From charming historic cottages to modern waterfront properties, there’s something for everyone. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of nature, sipping your morning coffee while gazing at the stunning river views, or gathering with friends and family around a cozy fireplace in your new home.

Explore the possibilities of life in Lyme, where tranquility meets adventure, and where your dream home awaits. Join this vibrant community and experience the enchanting lifestyle that makes Lyme, NY, truly special. Discover your perfect home today!

Newest Lyme Homes for Sale

$329,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1711639 MLS
This gorgeous waterfront cottage on Lake Ontario is just waiting to be yours! Completely remodeled over the past few years, this charming getaway features a new metal roof, kitchen appliances, hot water heater, water filtration system, renovated bathroom and bedrooms, plus spacious composite front and side decks—perfect for soaking up those beautiful lake views! Speaking of views! Always mesmerizing, you will get to watch the magnificent ships slowly pass by in the distance! With over 50 feet of waterfront, an amazing seawall, great swimming, kayaking, paddle boarding and even better fishing, this property offers everything you need to enjoy life on the lake! And the best part? It comes furnished! Indoor and outdoor furniture, decor, pots and pans, a grill, and so much more are included, making it easy to move right in and start enjoying your new waterfront retreat. Summer weather is still going strong—there’s time left to make this lake season yours! Don’t miss your chance to own a little piece of heaven on Lake Ontario!

24407 Hayes Bay Road, Lyme
$249,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1707854 MLS
If you are looking for a hobby farm with a starter home near Lake Ontario, check this place out! This beautifully updated 2-bedroom 1 bath home offers room to roam for you and your animals. All you need to do is show up and fill the barns and chicken coop. Along with 15 acres the property offers a 30x50 barn with generous space. This quiet little piece of heaven sits off Rt 12E a short distance from Lake Ontario and downtown restaurants. This is a dream property for a hobby farmer starting out or someone just looking for a cozy home with some room to stretch and care for their pets. Don't sit on this place.

13081 State Route 12e, Lyme
$310,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ S1709650 MLS
Your affordable waterfront getaway awaits on beautiful Chaumont Bay! This adorable and well maintained 2 bedroom, 1 bath ranch style cottage offers approximately 70 feet of waterfront and a fantastic level lot with easy access to the water. Spend your summers swimming, boating, fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, or simply relaxing and taking in the views. Currently enjoyed as a three season cottage, the property may offer potential for year round use with the addition of a shore well and possible insulation upgrades. Recent improvements include a new metal roof approximately two years ago and newer replacement windows, helping make this an easy, low maintenance retreat. As an added convenience, most furnishings will stay with the property, excluding the sellers' personal items, making it even easier to start enjoying lake life right away. If you have been dreaming of owning a place directly on the water without the upkeep of a larger property, this is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy everything Chaumont Bay and Lake Ontario have to offer. Pack your bags, bring the boat, and start making summer memories at the lake!

26959 Three Mile Point Road, Lyme
$449,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1710465 MLS
Cast a line, launch a kayak, or simply take in the views from this pristine, single-owner property on the Chaumont River! The home was built with extreme care and thought, and it shows! A garage and green house at the front of property greet you upon arrival, while a magnificent attached workshop is sure to please even the most discerning artist or craftsperson. The workshop (built in 2008) could be converted to a garage and features in-floor heat - though it is so well insulated, you may never need it! A spacious mudroom with storage connects the workshop to the house and also houses the laundry & utilities. Once inside, you enter to a good sized dining room and sitting room with incredible views of the river. The space is quipped with a gas fireplace and offers direct access to a sun porch & back deck. The kitchen is beautiful with ample counter & storage space and even more terrific views of the Chaumont River. The first floor of home also includes a bedroom with Murphy bed and a full bath. As you head upstairs, you pass through a roomy living room with vaulted ceilings and gorgeous wood beams - it's a real showstopper! The main bedroom with en suite bath overlooks the river below from a cozy window nook of windows, or possible balcony. The third bedrooms also features a custom-made Murphy bed that doubles as a desk when closed. These unique details are found throughout the home and reflect a craftsmanship that won't be found anywhere else. Even the sprawling lawn features charming vignettes and breathtaking landscaping that give the property an one-of-a-kind character. The back deck is truly magical, with gorgeous views and stellar sunsets. Follow a maintained path to the riverfront where you'll find an aluminum dock and huge screened pavilion, perfect for those that love the outdoors but want a more bug-free experience. The Chaumont River itself is great for paddling, fishing, boating, and other aquatic sports. You get the best of both worlds - quiet river life and the action of Lake Ontario just a few minutes downriver by boat! Homes like this are truly rare, so contact an agent today to learn more!

30005 County Route 179, Lyme
$310,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1709211 MLS
Welcome to this charming and beautifully maintained farmhouse-style home in the Village of Chaumont, offering a wonderful combination of character, quality, space, and modern updates. Set on an impressive 2.92 acres, this property offers a rare amount of land for a village location, along with two well-maintained red barns that add incredible character and versatility, retaining a functional chicken coop and hayloft space for storage, hobbies, or equipment. Inside, the home offers 5 spacious bedrooms and 2 recently updated full bathrooms, one on each floor. The main level features a large classic farmhouse kitchen that has been thoughtfully updated while maintaining its timeless charm. The kitchen flows beautifully into the formal dining room and an enormous 4-season sunroom. A distinctive living room sits centrally between the two levels at an elevated height, creating an inviting focal point complete with a large central viewing window. The kitchen and dining areas showcase beautiful high-end engineered hardwood flooring, while the rest of the home features like-new luxury vinyl plank flooring. Upstairs, the recently updated space includes a very large primary bedroom set apart from the other rooms for added privacy, along with an oversized walk-in closet/storage room. Outside, a wide-open backyard offers plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. Charming tree swings add a nostalgic touch, while a dedicated fire pit area provides the perfect setting for evenings outside. The expansive front deck is brand new and offers a welcoming entrance for guests and everyday enjoyment, and the main house features a 5-year-old metal roof in excellent condition. With its generous acreage, two barns, substantial living space, beautiful flooring, oversized sunroom, unique floor plan, and classic farmhouse character, this move-in-ready property pairs the charm of country living with true village convenience - walking distance to the K-12 school, library, post office, restaurants, and the summer farmers market, with the Sally Port event center just ten minutes away in Three Mile Bay.

8109 County Route 125, Lyme
$649,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1709109 MLS
Discover this stunning year-round riverfront ranch, perfectly situated on the mouth of the Chaumont River and just a stone's throw away to Lake Ontario. This beautifully maintained four-bedroom, three-bath home rests on a generous lot, blending privacy with accessibility just a short walk from the charming village. Upon entering, you'll be greeted by a spacious open floor plan filled with natural light, seamlessly connecting the living areas. The heart of the home is the gorgeous living room that overlooks the river, complemented by a beautifully appointed kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances and an quaint dining area. Enjoy panoramic views of the Chaumont River, with sliding glass doors that lead to an expansive deck—an ideal spot for entertaining or relaxing with your morning coffee in serene surroundings. The thoughtfully designed layout includes Brazilian hardwood floors throughout, ensuring style and comfort. The primary suite serves as a true retreat, boasting an en-suite bath and picturesque views. Located right at the entrance to Chaumont Bay, this property is renowned for year-round world-class fishing, as well as opportunities for swimming, boating, and wildlife watching. For boating enthusiasts, the river offers excellent protection and deep-water access for larger vessels, making it a prime location for water activities. Plus, it's conveniently situated just minutes from restaurants, shops, marinas, and public beaches, providing an exceptional lifestyle in an unbeatable location. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this stunning riverfront property your forever home!

27747 Water Street, Lyme
$199,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1709165 MLS
Discover the charm and potential of this 1850 farmhouse, nestled on 1.3 acres and offering the perfect opportunity for a hobby farm or country lifestyle. Thoughtfully renovated and improved, this 3-bedroom home combines historic character with comfortable modern living. The first floor features a beautiful country kitchen, bedroom with a very spacious walk-in closet, along with a convenient half bath and laundry. Upstairs, you will find two additional bedrooms, including a spacious primary bedroom, as well as a full bath. An attached 1.5-car garage provides plenty of room for parking and storage. Outside, the property offers a small storage shed and a 12 x 20 barn complete with two stalls, making it ideal for a horse, donkey, or other small livestock. With 1.03 acres to enjoy, this property offers room to garden, raise animals, or simply embrace the peaceful country setting. A wonderful opportunity to own a piece of farmhouse history with the space and improvements to make it your own!

26581 County Route 6, Lyme
$670,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1707604 MLS
Discover a rare waterfront retreat set on over 5 acres of private land with approximately 150 feet of sandy shoreline and expansive water views. This custom built 4 bedroom, 2 bath home offers a unique combination of privacy, waterfront recreation, and space to enjoy both indoors and out. A gated driveway winds through mature trees and natural surroundings to the secluded residence. Inside, expansive windows and a sliding glass door create a natural connection to the outdoors, opening to a large concrete patio overlooking the water. The generous waterfront grounds provide plenty of space for entertaining, relaxing, swimming, kayaking, or considering future improvements (subject to applicable approval) The sandy shoreline features a walkout waterfront with convenient access to the water, while groomed trails throughout the property provide additional ways to explore the acreage. An extensive collection of recreational items conveys with the property, including a four wheeler, dune buggy, golf cart, roll out docks, jet ski, kayak, paddle boat, row boat, sailboat, and mower. Furnishings are also included, providing a convenient opportunity for a turnkey waterfront getaway or a potential income producing property! With substantial acreage, private waterfront, mature trees, recreational amenities, and multiple areas to enjoy the setting, this property offers a distinctive opportunity to own and make the most of waterfront living!

27560 County Route 57, Lyme
$80,000
1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1705430 MLS
Affordable year-round one-bedroom, one-bath home offering a great opportunity for buyers looking for a property they can update and personalize. Priced at $80,000, the home is in need of some cosmetic improvements and general updating, including patching, painting, flooring, light fixtures, cleaning, and basic carpentry repairs. The property provides a solid opportunity for an owner-occupant, seasonal buyer, or investor who is comfortable completing improvements over time and creating a space that reflects their own style and needs. The location is one of the property’s most appealing features, situated as the last home on the south side of the river before it enters Lake Ontario and conveniently located as the first home before crossing the new Chaumont bridge. Enjoy close proximity to boating, fishing, waterfront recreation, local dining, and the many amenities the Chaumont area has to offer. With some attention, updating, and care, this property has plenty of potential to become an enjoyable year-round residence, seasonal retreat, or investment property. If you are looking for an affordable home in a desirable waterfront community and are not afraid to take on some improvements, this property is well worth a look. Schedule your private showing today and explore the possibilities. Photo Disclaimer: Some listing photographs have been digitally enhanced for presentation purposes.

27651 Water Street, Lyme
$299,900
S1705161 MLS
Look at this incredible opportunity! Situated on more than 2 acres with nearly 200 feet of protected waterfront overlooking beautiful Chaumont Bay, this property is ready for you to make it your own. The hard work has already been done—now all that's left is for you to complete the interior. Imagine designing your ideal floor plan and adding your own personal style and finishes to this recently built pier-on-slab home. The exterior is complete and features a spacious wraparound deck with cable railings that maximize the stunning water views, low-maintenance vinyl siding, sliding glass doors, and energy-efficient vinyl windows. A new septic system is in place ready for hook up. The impressive 40' x 28' pole barn provides abundant storage for all your recreational equipment, including boats, ATVs, vehicles, campers, and more. Now it's your turn to bring the interior to life. Create the home you've always envisioned, tailored to your lifestyle and tastes. Whether you're dreaming of a seasonal getaway, or a unique investment opportunity, this property offers the perfect canvas in an exceptional setting. Enjoy the privacy of a large waterfront parcel, the beauty of Chaumont Bay, and the rare opportunity to finish a home exactly the way you want it. Don't miss your chance to transform this waterfront gem into something truly special. Please do not pull into the property. Viewing is by appointment only.

24830 County Route 57, Lyme
$775,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1702506 MLS
This custom built home offers exceptional quality, thoughtful design, and 75 feet of stunning waterfront on a peaceful shoreline. Built in 2011 with a major addition completed in 2020, this property is a rare combination of luxury, functionality, and beauty. A standout feature of the property is the exceptional 40' x 60' Amish-built garage and workshop, built just five years ago to an outstanding standard. This premium building features a steel roof and siding, three oversized bays, full insulation, finished plywood interior walls, LED lighting, propane heat, water, electric, and Wi-Fi. A spacious 16' x 60' second-story storage loft with elevator access provides even more versatility. The shop also houses a solar array that offsets approximately 95% of the property's annual electrical costs, keeping total electric expenses to just $1,000–$1,300 per year. With ample depth for multiple vehicles, boats, or even a full-size motorhome, this elite outbuilding is an incredible addition to the property. The main home features 2256 sq ft, with the extra sq footage coming from the loft space, 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. The main level offers two spacious bedrooms with elegant finishes and a full bathroom and tiled walk-in shower. The heart of the home includes a living room with stunning water views and a beautifully finished kitchen, and high-end appliances. The large family room addition is a true showstopper—complete with a real stone fireplace, in-floor heat powered by a propane-fired boiler, a minisplit for independent heating and cooling. Upstairs, the loft offers a third bedroom, full bath, and flexible space currently used as an office and sitting area. Stonework leading to the water, a private dock (best suited for pontoons). In addition to the main barn this property has multiple other outbuildings including a 24x32 garage insulated with pine walls, used for parking and storage. 12x20 she-shed with metal roof. Wood shed, garden storage. The wraparound deck with composite wood with 2024 upgrades adds fantastic entertaining space. This is the total package-custom craftsmanship, energy efficiency, & waterfront beauty. Call today!

6938 Klock Road, Lyme
$285,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1703677 MLS
Enjoy the perfect combination of privacy, space, and waterfront recreation without the high waterfront taxes! This beautifully updated 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom ranch sits on 2 peaceful acres and includes 15 feet of deeded water access, making it easy to enjoy fishing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and more. Built in 2005, this 1,536 square foot home features a bright, open concept layout where the living room, dining area, and kitchen flow seamlessly together, creating the perfect space for entertaining or everyday living. The kitchen offers warm butcher block countertops, stainless steel appliances, and plenty of workspace. Fresh paint and new flooring throughout give the home a clean, modern feel. The spacious primary suite includes a private full bath, while three additional bedrooms provide plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, extensive tree clearing has created an even larger backyard with endless possibilities for recreation, gardening, or simply relaxing. A storage shed provides additional space for tools and outdoor equipment. Whether you're looking for a year round residence or a weekend getaway, this property offers the best of country living with the added bonus of deeded waterfront access at a fraction of the taxes of true waterfront ownership.

20432 S Shore Road, Lyme
Start Your Search